Your car is towed to your local repair shop and the mechanic calls you a few hours later to say you need a new transmission. Now what?

You’re probably wondering how to find reliable automotive repair that’s worth your money. It's a tough decision with many factors to consider.

Repairing Your Car Instead of Replacing It

There are many reasons to consider repairing your vehicle instead of replacing it. But is that the best financial choice? Here are some things to think about:

• If your car is paid off, you've already made all the payments, and now you're looking at another down payment or monthly payment. Is that something you're ready for?
• If your car is less than four years old and has been reliable, it might last several more years after a major repair with proper maintenance.
• If you want to keep your insurance and registration costs the same as your car ages, repairs could help you avoid higher expenses.
• If you’ve already taken the depreciation hit on your car, it may not be worth spending more on a new one right now.
• If you know your car well and have experienced its quirks, you might feel more comfortable fixing it than buying a new one.
• If you don’t want the hassle of shopping for a new car, repairing your current one could save time and stress.

There are valid reasons to keep your vehicle, authorize the repair, and hope for the best. However, you don’t want to keep pouring money into a car that keeps needing more work.

Buying Another Car Instead of Repairing It

Here are some reasons to consider getting rid of your car rather than investing in expensive repairs:

• If large repairs are becoming frequent, it might be a sign that your car isn’t worth keeping.
• If the repair cost is over half the value of your car, it might not be financially wise to fix it.
• If you were planning to buy a new car anyway due to changing circumstances, this could be a good opportunity.
• If your car is older and lacks modern technology and safety features, it might be time for an upgrade.
• If your fuel efficiency is dropping, it might be a sign that your car is not performing well anymore.
• If your car no longer has a warranty, any repair will come out of your pocket.
• If your car often breaks down and leaves you stranded, it might not be safe or reliable enough to keep.

There are advantages to getting rid of your old car. For example, you can invest in a safer, more efficient model. You might also get some money back by selling it. Don’t just compare the repair cost to the car’s value—consider the long-term benefits of a newer vehicle.

When making such decisions, gather as much information as possible. Don’t let an emergency situation pressure you into a choice you might regret later.

Preventative Maintenance Is Always Key

There’s no way around the “repair or replace” dilemma. It’s up to you as the owner to decide. There are steps you can take to keep your car running smoothly.

Work with your local auto repair shop to keep your vehicle in top condition. Address minor issues quickly before they become costly problems.

Your First Line of Defense: You

Here are some daily actions you can take to avoid facing the difficult decision of paying for a large repair or replacing your car early:

Regular Auto Maintenance

Follow the recommended inspections and maintenance checks in your car manual. Many people think these services are unnecessary, but neglect can lead to serious mechanical failures. Pay attention to warning signs like the "check engine" light. Ignoring them can lead to bigger problems and higher costs.

Check Fluid Levels

Maintaining proper fluid levels is essential. Fluids help your car run smoothly and safely. Check oil, wiper fluid, and antifreeze yourself, and ask your mechanic for help with others like transmission fluid or brake fluid.

Take Care of the Tires

Tire health affects your car’s overall performance. Proper inflation and regular rotation prevent uneven wear and reduce strain on the chassis and wheels.

Replace Filters

A dirty air filter affects fuel efficiency and acceleration. Replace it regularly, either yourself or during routine service. A clogged fuel filter can damage the engine, while a dirty cabin filter impacts HVAC performance.

Taking care of your car is always smarter than ignoring potential issues. Your car is an investment, so maintain it properly.

Book Appointment

Your Second Line of Defense: Your Auto Shop and Mechanic

It’s important to have a trusted auto shop and mechanic. At Lamb’s Tire & Automotive, we prioritize your best interests. We diagnose the problem and suggest the best course of action. Most drivers aren't experts, so having a professional on your side is crucial.

Build a relationship with your mechanic. They can guide you through necessary inspections and preventative maintenance, such as oil changes, tire checks, battery tests, and fluid checks.

Many of these checks can be done together. Discuss with your service team to get the most value from your visits. Good shops keep records that help with future repairs.

See Our Auto Repair Coupons

Some Major Repairs That May Not Be Worth the Cost

If you’re considering a costly repair, here are some that may not be worth it:

Engine Replacement

An engine replacement can cost between $3,000 and $7,000. If your car is over 5 years old, it may not be worth the expense.

Head Gasket Replacement

Replacing a head gasket can cost $1,200 to $1,500. This often leads to more expensive repairs, so it’s not always a good investment.

Transmission Replacement

Replacing a transmission is expensive, starting at $5,000. It’s hard to justify this cost if your car has high mileage.

Bent Frame Repair

A bent frame can cost up to $10,000 to fix. It also affects other critical systems, making the car unsafe.

Steering Rack Replacement

Replacing a steering rack can cost between $640 and $1,200. It’s essential for safety and should be addressed promptly.

Catalytic Converter Replacement

This repair can cost around $2,500. Without it, your car won’t pass emissions tests.

Heater Core Replacement

A failed heater core can cause other system damage, leading to a minimum cost of $1,000.

Air Conditioner Compressor Replacement

Fixing an AC compressor can cost over $1,000. Other systems may also be affected, increasing the total cost.

Clutch Replacement

A clutch replacement can cost $1,500 or more. It often indicates larger issues with the transmission.

Complete Brake Job

Replacing the entire brake system can cost over $1,000. Older cars may need additional repairs soon after.

It’s a Big Decision

Deciding whether to repair or replace your car is never easy. As the owner, you’re the one who must make the call.

Consider the pros and cons before an emergency arises. Build a relationship with your local auto shop and stay on top of routine maintenance. Don’t ignore problems—address them as soon as they appear.

At Lamb’s Tire & Automotive, we’re here to help. Schedule an appointment today and make an informed decision about your car’s future.

Book Appointment

Frequently Asked Questions